written by
Dorea Hardy

​Building Trust with Faculty: The Foundation of Effective Instructional Design Partnerships

Instructional Design Leadership 18 min read , November 16, 2026

Have you ever walked into a meeting with a faculty member and immediately sensed that they weren't particularly excited to see you? Perhaps they crossed their arms, explained that they'd been teaching successfully for twenty years, or made it clear that they weren't interested in changing their course. You arrived prepared to discuss learning objectives, assessments, and course organization, but suddenly the conversation felt more like a negotiation than a collaboration.

If you've worked in instructional design long enough, you've probably experienced some version of this situation. And if you're new to the profession, don't worry. Your turn will come.

The challenge is that instructional designers often enter faculty consultations focused on improving courses, while faculty members may be focused on protecting something they've spent years developing. They bring disciplinary knowledge, teaching experience, established practices, and professional expectations to the conversation. When we overlook those contributions, even well-intended recommendations can feel like criticism.

Effective instructional design partnerships begin with trust, not technology, templates, or checklists.

Trust doesn't mean faculty will agree with every recommendation or that instructional designers should avoid difficult conversations. It means establishing a working relationship in which both individuals feel respected, understand their responsibilities, and can discuss instructional challenges without becoming defensive.

In this article, we'll examine why trust matters in faculty relationships, what can undermine it, and how instructional designers can build productive partnerships that support both faculty and student success.

Why Trust Matters in Instructional Design

Instructional design is often described as a process involving analysis, design, development, implementation, and evaluation. Those activities are important, but they don't happen independently of the people responsible for creating and delivering instruction. In higher education, instructional designers frequently depend on faculty members to provide disciplinary content, explain instructional expectations, make academic decisions, and participate in course development.

That means much of our work depends on collaboration.

An instructional designer may identify a problem with assessment alignment, course navigation, or student engagement. However, identifying the problem is only part of the work. The designer must also communicate the concern, explain its instructional importance, and work with the faculty member to develop an appropriate solution.

Without trust, even reasonable recommendations can encounter resistance. Faculty may question the designer's understanding of their discipline, interpret feedback as criticism, or become reluctant to share concerns about their teaching. They may complete required tasks without fully participating in the design process.

When trust exists, those conversations become easier. Faculty are more likely to explain what they're trying to accomplish, acknowledge areas where they need assistance, and consider instructional approaches they haven't previously used.

Trust doesn't guarantee agreement, but it creates conditions in which meaningful collaboration becomes possible.

Faculty Members Bring More Than Content Knowledge

One of the quickest ways to damage a faculty relationship is to treat the instructor as little more than a source of course content.

Instructional designers sometimes describe faculty members as subject matter experts, or SMEs. The term is appropriate in many contexts, but it can unintentionally narrow how we view their contributions. Faculty members may also bring years of teaching experience, knowledge of student challenges, disciplinary expectations, professional standards, and established approaches to assessment.

Consider a history professor who has taught political movements for more than two decades. That instructor may understand which historical arguments students commonly misunderstand, which primary sources generate meaningful discussion, and where learners struggle to connect events across different periods. Those observations can provide information that isn't immediately visible in a syllabus or collection of lecture slides.

An instructional designer brings a different set of knowledge to the partnership. We examine learning objectives, instructional alignment, accessibility, cognitive demands, assessment strategies, and the learning environment. Our contribution is not replacing the faculty member's disciplinary knowledge but helping translate that knowledge into effective learning experiences.

Strong partnerships acknowledge both forms of professional knowledge.

When faculty members understand that instructional designers respect their teaching experience, they're more likely to view the relationship as collaborative rather than corrective. And when instructional designers take the time to learn from faculty, they often make better recommendations.

Start by Listening, Not Recommending

One of the most useful habits an instructional designer can develop is resisting the urge to solve every problem immediately.

Imagine a faculty member explaining that students rarely participate in online discussions. Before the instructor finishes describing the situation, the instructional designer begins recommending new discussion prompts, grading rubrics, and participation requirements. Those suggestions might eventually be appropriate, but the designer hasn't yet determined why students aren't participating.

Perhaps the prompts are too restrictive. Perhaps students don't understand what meaningful participation looks like. Maybe the discussions aren't connected to other learning activities, or the instructor is concerned that students are posting superficial responses simply to earn points.

Each possibility suggests a different solution.

A more productive conversation begins with questions about the instructor's expectations and experiences. What does successful participation look like in this course? What have students done in previous semesters? Which discussions have generated the strongest responses? What would the instructor like students to gain from the activity?

Listening communicates respect while providing information needed to make an informed recommendation.

It also demonstrates that the instructional designer isn't arriving with a predetermined solution. The faculty member becomes a participant in identifying the problem rather than someone being told what needs to change.

Understand What Faculty Are Trying to Protect

Faculty resistance is sometimes interpreted as an unwillingness to change. However, hesitation may reflect concern about losing something the instructor considers important.

An instructor who relies heavily on classroom discussions may worry that asynchronous activities won't provide the same opportunities for spontaneous conversation. Someone who uses detailed written assignments may be concerned that alternative assessments won't adequately measure disciplinary reasoning. Another faculty member may resist shortening recorded lectures because they believe students need the complete explanation to understand difficult concepts.

These concerns deserve consideration, even when the proposed instructional approach could be improved.

The instructional designer's responsibility is to understand the purpose behind the existing practice. If an instructor values spontaneous discussion, we can examine how online activities might support meaningful exchanges and opportunities for follow-up. If detailed explanation is important, we can consider how instructional content might be organized into manageable segments without sacrificing intellectual depth.

The goal isn't preserving every existing teaching practice simply because it is familiar. It's understanding what makes that practice meaningful before recommending a different approach.

When faculty members see that we're trying to preserve the instructional purpose rather than eliminate their preferred methods, they're often more willing to consider alternatives.

Be Clear About Your Role

Instructional designers occupy an interesting position in higher education. We may be responsible for supporting course quality, helping faculty meet institutional expectations, and recommending evidence-informed instructional strategies. However, we typically do not have direct authority over every instructional decision made by the faculty members we support.

That relationship can create confusion if expectations aren't established early.

Some faculty members may assume the instructional designer is primarily a technology support specialist. Others may believe the designer is responsible for creating all course materials. Still others may view instructional design consultation as a review process intended to identify mistakes.

Clear communication helps prevent these misunderstandings.

At the beginning of a project, explain what the instructional design partnership involves, which responsibilities belong to the faculty member, and where the instructional designer will provide support. Discuss development timelines, communication expectations, review processes, and any institutional requirements that apply.

It's also important to distinguish between recommendations and requirements. A consistent module structure may be strongly recommended because it improves usability, while an applicable accessibility requirement must be satisfied. Presenting personal preferences as institutional mandates can undermine credibility, just as treating mandatory requirements as optional can create serious problems.

Trust grows when faculty members understand what to expect and know that the instructional designer will communicate accurately.

Follow Through on What You Promise

Trust isn't built through a single successful meeting. It develops through repeated experiences that demonstrate reliability.

If you promise to send a faculty member a sample rubric, send it. If you agree to investigate a learning management system issue, provide an update even if the problem hasn't been resolved. If you establish a course development deadline, communicate early when circumstances require an adjustment.

These actions may seem ordinary, but they establish an important pattern. Faculty members learn that they can depend on the instructional designer to do what was discussed.

The opposite is also true.

Missed deadlines, unanswered messages, inconsistent guidance, and unclear expectations can quickly weaken a relationship. Faculty members who already feel uncertain about course development may become even more reluctant to participate when they don't know whether support will be available.

Reliability doesn't require being available at every moment or immediately solving every problem. It requires communicating realistic expectations and following through consistently.

Sometimes a simple message explaining that an issue is still being investigated does more to maintain trust than remaining silent until a solution is available.

Avoid Making Faculty Feel Judged

Course reviews and consultations frequently reveal opportunities for improvement. Assignments may not align clearly with learning objectives, navigation may be inconsistent, or instructional materials may present accessibility barriers. Addressing those concerns is part of the instructional designer's responsibility.

However, the way feedback is communicated can determine whether a faculty member becomes receptive or defensive.

Consider the difference between telling an instructor that their discussion questions are ineffective and explaining that the current prompts may encourage students to summarize information rather than analyze it. The second approach identifies an instructional concern and opens the door to discussing alternatives.

Similarly, telling a faculty member that their course is poorly organized may create unnecessary tension. Explaining that students must navigate several different locations to locate weekly assignments provides a more specific and actionable observation.

Effective feedback focuses on the learning experience rather than making judgments about the instructor.

That doesn't mean avoiding direct communication. If a course contains a serious accessibility problem or fails to meet an established requirement, the issue must be addressed clearly. However, we can communicate the concern professionally without implying that the faculty member is careless or incapable.

Faculty are more likely to consider recommendations when they understand that the goal is improving the course, not evaluating their worth as educators.

Make Your Reasoning Visible

Instructional designers sometimes make recommendations that seem obvious to us because we're familiar with learning theories, accessibility standards, and course design principles. Faculty members may not share that background, and they shouldn't be expected to accept every suggestion without understanding its purpose.

Explaining the reasoning behind a recommendation helps build professional credibility.

For example, instead of simply recommending that a lengthy assignment description be reorganized, explain how headings, short sections, and clearly identified submission requirements can help students locate information. Rather than insisting that an assessment rubric needs revision, demonstrate how the current criteria may not fully measure the intended learning outcomes.

These explanations help faculty understand the relationship between instructional decisions and student learning.

They also create opportunities for professional development within the consultation itself. Faculty members begin learning why particular design approaches are recommended and may apply those principles independently in future courses.

This is especially important when working with experienced instructors. They may not need someone to tell them how to teach, but they may appreciate understanding how instructional design principles can strengthen their existing practices.

Professional credibility grows when recommendations are supported by clear reasoning rather than simply presented as the instructional designer's preferred approach.

Respect Faculty Time and Workload

Faculty members often balance teaching, research, advising, service, and administrative responsibilities. Course development may be one project among many competing demands. When instructional designers overlook those responsibilities, even reasonable requests can feel overwhelming.

Imagine asking a faculty member to revise every assignment, record new instructional videos, update course materials, and develop additional assessments within a short period. Each recommendation may have instructional merit, but the combined workload may be unrealistic.

A more collaborative approach involves discussing priorities and establishing a manageable development plan.

Identify what must be completed before the course begins, what can be improved during a later revision cycle, and which activities require the faculty member's direct involvement. Provide clear instructions and examples that reduce unnecessary decision-making. When appropriate, offer templates or sample materials that help faculty complete tasks more efficiently.

Respecting workload does not mean lowering course quality expectations or postponing mandatory requirements. It means recognizing that time and resources influence how instructional improvements can be implemented.

Faculty members are more likely to trust an instructional designer who understands their professional responsibilities and helps them manage the work realistically.

Small Successes Build Confidence

Not every faculty partnership needs to begin with a complete course redesign. Sometimes the most effective way to build trust is to work together on one manageable improvement.

A faculty member who is skeptical about instructional design may be more willing to revise a single assignment than reconsider an entire course. Another instructor may agree to reorganize one module or experiment with a different discussion format.

These smaller projects provide opportunities to demonstrate the benefits of instructional design.

Suppose an instructor frequently receives student questions about assignment requirements. Together, the faculty member and instructional designer revise the instructions, organize them under clear headings, and develop a concise checklist. During the next offering, the instructor notices fewer questions about what students are expected to submit.

That experience provides practical evidence that thoughtful design can improve the teaching process.

Of course, not every improvement produces an immediately measurable result. However, successful collaboration on smaller tasks can create confidence in the relationship and make larger projects feel more manageable.

Trust often develops through these ordinary experiences rather than dramatic transformations.

Disagreement Doesn't Have to Damage the Relationship

Even strong instructional design partnerships involve disagreement. Faculty members may prefer instructional approaches that differ from the designer's recommendations, and instructional designers may identify concerns that instructors don't initially consider important.

The goal isn't eliminating disagreement. It's creating a professional relationship in which different viewpoints can be discussed constructively.

When disagreement occurs, return to the instructional purpose. What should students learn? What evidence will demonstrate that learning? What barriers might the proposed approach introduce? Are there institutional requirements that influence the decision?

These questions help move the conversation away from personal preferences and toward instructional reasoning.

It's also important to acknowledge when more than one approach could be effective. Instructional design rarely offers a single perfect solution for every situation. Explaining the advantages and limitations of different options allows faculty members to participate meaningfully in decisions.

When a faculty member chooses an approach that differs from the designer's preference but still meets the learning objectives and applicable requirements, that decision may be entirely reasonable.

Trust grows when faculty members know that collaboration doesn't require agreeing with the instructional designer on every detail.

Confidentiality and Professional Respect Matter

Faculty consultations sometimes involve sensitive conversations about teaching challenges, student performance, course evaluations, or previous instructional decisions. Faculty members may disclose concerns they would hesitate to discuss in a larger meeting.

Instructional designers should handle those conversations with appropriate discretion.

An instructor who admits struggling with online discussions may be taking a professional risk by acknowledging uncertainty. If that conversation later becomes an example shared casually with colleagues, the faculty member may feel embarrassed or betrayed.

Maintaining professional boundaries is essential. Discuss course concerns with individuals who have a legitimate responsibility for addressing them, follow institutional reporting procedures, and avoid unnecessary sharing of identifiable information.

There may be circumstances in which instructional designers must report compliance concerns or communicate course development problems to supervisors. Those responsibilities should be handled through appropriate institutional processes rather than informal conversations.

Professional respect also includes giving faculty credit for their contributions. When a course improvement results from collaboration, acknowledge the instructor's disciplinary knowledge and participation rather than presenting the outcome as the instructional designer's accomplishment alone.

Faculty members are more likely to engage openly when they know their concerns will be treated responsibly and their contributions respected.

Trust Is Especially Important During Course Reviews

Course quality reviews can create anxiety, particularly when faculty members are unfamiliar with the review process. Even when a review is intended to support improvement, instructors may interpret it as an evaluation of their teaching abilities.

Instructional designers can reduce unnecessary anxiety by explaining the purpose and scope of the review before it begins.

Clarify what will be examined, which standards or criteria apply, how feedback will be communicated, and what opportunities exist for revisions. When possible, provide examples of how course elements demonstrate alignment with the review criteria.

Feedback should distinguish between requirements that have not been met and recommendations that could strengthen the learning experience. This distinction helps faculty prioritize their work and prevents the review from feeling like an endless collection of personal preferences.

The tone of the review matters as well. Identifying strengths alongside areas for improvement demonstrates that the reviewer is examining the course thoughtfully rather than simply searching for problems.

When faculty understand that the review process is intended to support course quality, they're more likely to participate constructively. Trust doesn't eliminate the responsibility to apply standards consistently, but it makes those standards easier to discuss and implement.

Building Trust Takes Time

One of the realities of instructional design is that trust cannot be established through a single conversation or a perfectly prepared presentation. Faculty members develop confidence in instructional designers through repeated interactions, particularly when those interactions involve difficult decisions or competing priorities.

An instructor may initially approach a consultation cautiously, especially if previous experiences with instructional support were frustrating. Over time, reliable communication, respectful feedback, and useful recommendations can change that perception.

It's important not to interpret every hesitant response as a personal rejection. Faculty members may be managing deadlines, responding to institutional changes, or feeling uncertain about unfamiliar expectations. Those circumstances can influence how they participate in course development.

Instructional designers should remain consistent in their professional approach without expecting immediate enthusiasm.

Sometimes progress looks like a faculty member agreeing to reconsider an assessment. Other times, it looks like an instructor asking for advice before making a course change. Eventually, it may look like that same faculty member recommending instructional design support to a colleague.

Those moments indicate that the relationship has developed beyond completing required tasks.

The faculty member now sees the instructional designer as a trusted professional resource.

Trust Creates Opportunities for Better Teaching

The benefits of strong faculty relationships extend beyond individual course development projects. When instructors trust instructional designers, they're more likely to seek guidance early, discuss instructional challenges openly, and consider improvements before problems become difficult to correct.

This can change the nature of instructional design work.

Instead of being contacted only when a course needs immediate repairs, instructional designers may become involved during initial planning. Faculty may request assistance with learning objectives, assessment strategies, accessibility, or student engagement before materials are fully developed.

Early collaboration creates more opportunities to make thoughtful instructional decisions.

Trust can also contribute to a broader culture of professional learning. Faculty members who have positive experiences with instructional design may share those experiences with colleagues, participate in development opportunities, or become advocates for effective online teaching practices.

The relationship between one faculty member and one instructional designer may seem relatively small, but those partnerships can influence how instructional support is perceived across a department or institution.

This is one reason relationship-building deserves as much attention as technical and design skills. Instructional designers may understand how to create effective learning experiences, but trust helps make it possible to put that knowledge into practice.

Final Thoughts

Building trust with faculty is not a separate responsibility that instructional designers address after completing their technical work. It is part of the work itself. Effective course development depends on communication, collaboration, professional respect, and a shared commitment to student learning.

Faculty members bring disciplinary knowledge, teaching experience, and professional responsibilities to the partnership. Instructional designers contribute knowledge about learning, assessment, accessibility, course organization, and educational technology. When both contributions are respected, the relationship becomes more productive and the resulting instructional decisions are often stronger.

Trust develops through listening, explaining recommendations, respecting workload, communicating clearly, maintaining professional boundaries, and following through on commitments. It also requires a willingness to have difficult conversations without turning every disagreement into a contest over who knows best.

Perhaps most importantly, instructional designers need to remember that faculty members are not simply obstacles to overcome or individuals who must be persuaded to accept our recommendations. They are professional colleagues who share responsibility for creating meaningful learning experiences.

The strongest instructional design partnerships don't begin with proving that we have the answers. They begin with demonstrating that we're willing to listen, collaborate, and work toward solutions together.

And sometimes, building that relationship is the most important instructional design work we do.

References

Bates, A. W. (2022). Teaching in a digital age: Guidelines for designing teaching and learning (3rd ed.). Tony Bates Associates Ltd. https://pressbooks.bccampus.ca/teachinginadigitalagev3m/

Bovill, C. (2020). Co-creation in learning and teaching: The case for a whole-class approach in higher education. Higher Education, 79, 1023–1037. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-019-00453-w

Ertmer, P. A. (1999). Addressing first- and second-order barriers to change: Strategies for technology integration. Educational Technology Research and Development, 47(4), 47–61. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02299597

Kezar, A. (2014). How colleges change: Understanding, leading, and enacting change. Routledge.

Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5th ed.). Free Press.

Schön, D. A. (1983). The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. Basic Books.

instructional design Faculty Collaboration Building Trust Faculty Development Instructional Design Consulting Faculty Relationships Instructional Design Leadership higher education Professional Communication course development