Imagine enrolling in a professional development course to strengthen skills you've been using for more than a decade. You're excited about learning something new, but within the first few minutes, you discover that every activity is prescribed, every example is unrelated to your work, and every assignment must be completed in exactly the same way. You have no opportunity to draw upon your experience, select topics that interest you, or demonstrate what you know through methods that make sense for your professional goals. Before long, you begin wondering whether the course was designed for experienced adults or for learners who have never encountered the subject before.
Adult learners bring a lifetime of experiences, responsibilities, preferences, and goals into every learning environment. They may be returning to higher education after years in the workforce, completing professional certifications, changing careers, or pursuing personal interests. Unlike learners who have little experience with a subject, many adults already possess knowledge they can connect to new concepts. They also tend to have clear reasons for participating in learning experiences, even when those reasons differ considerably from one person to another.
One of the most effective ways instructional designers can acknowledge these differences is by incorporating meaningful choice into learning experiences. Choice allows learners to exercise some control over how they engage with material, connect new knowledge to personal goals, and demonstrate what they have learned. However, effective choice is not simply allowing students to do whatever they want. It requires thoughtful instructional design that balances learner autonomy with clear expectations and meaningful learning outcomes. This article examines why choice matters in adult learning, how it supports motivation and self-direction, and how instructional designers can incorporate flexibility without sacrificing academic rigor.
Adult Learners Bring Experience and Expectations
One of the foundational principles of adult learning theory is that adults bring prior experiences that influence how they approach new information. Malcolm Knowles' work on andragogy describes adult learners as increasingly self-directed and interested in understanding why learning is relevant to their lives. Although these characteristics do not describe every adult in every situation, they provide a useful starting point for designing learning experiences that acknowledge learner independence.
Consider two students enrolled in the same graduate-level instructional design course. One has spent fifteen years teaching in higher education and wants to improve online course development. The other recently completed an undergraduate degree and hopes to begin a career in corporate training. Both need to understand instructional design principles, but their professional goals and existing knowledge differ considerably. A course that assumes everyone shares the same background may unintentionally limit the relevance of its learning activities.
Providing meaningful choices allows learners to connect common course objectives with their individual experiences. The experienced faculty member might evaluate an existing university course, while the aspiring corporate trainer could analyze a workplace onboarding program. Both learners would apply the same instructional design principles, but each would do so in a context that supports their goals. This approach respects differences without requiring completely separate courses.
Choice Supports Learner Autonomy
Autonomy refers to the experience of having meaningful control over one's actions and decisions. Within Self-Determination Theory, autonomy is one of three basic psychological needs associated with motivation, alongside competence and relatedness. When learners experience an appropriate degree of autonomy, they may become more willing to engage with challenging activities because they understand and accept the purpose behind their participation.
In educational settings, autonomy does not mean eliminating expectations or allowing learners to ignore required work. Instead, it involves providing meaningful opportunities for decision-making within a clearly established instructional structure. Learners might select a research topic, choose among comparable case studies, determine which professional context to investigate, or decide how to organize a project. These decisions allow learners to exercise ownership while continuing to work toward the same learning objectives.
The distinction between meaningful autonomy and unrestricted freedom is important. A course with no clear expectations can create uncertainty rather than motivation, particularly for learners who are unfamiliar with the subject. Instructional designers should provide enough structure to support progress while allowing flexibility where different approaches can achieve the same outcome. Choice works best when learners understand both the available options and the expectations that apply to them.
Not All Choices Are Equally Meaningful
Instructional designers sometimes introduce choice by allowing learners to select between options that have little instructional relevance. Students might choose the color of a presentation template, select a decorative image, or decide whether to submit an assignment on Tuesday or Wednesday. These decisions may provide convenience or personal preference, but they do not necessarily increase meaningful autonomy or engagement.
More useful choices connect directly to learner goals, interests, or approaches to demonstrating knowledge. For example, allowing students to select a real-world problem related to their profession can make an assignment more personally relevant. Providing several case studies involving different industries may help learners recognize how a concept applies beyond the examples used during instruction. Allowing learners to investigate a question that genuinely interests them can also encourage deeper engagement with course material.
However, choice should not be added simply because it sounds learner-centered. Every option should support the intended learning outcomes and remain appropriate for the assessment. If learners are expected to demonstrate written communication skills, allowing them to replace a written assignment with an unrelated visual presentation may not provide equivalent evidence of achievement. Meaningful choice requires understanding which elements of an activity are essential and which can be flexible.
Choice Can Strengthen Motivation
Adult learners often participate in education because they have specific goals. Some want to advance professionally, while others hope to change careers, earn credentials, improve their teaching, or develop personal interests. When learning activities connect with those goals, the work can feel more purposeful and relevant. Choice provides one way to help learners establish that connection.
Imagine a professional development workshop about using educational technology. One instructor wants to improve online discussions, another needs better methods for providing feedback, and a third is interested in organizing course materials more effectively. Requiring everyone to complete an identical project may provide foundational practice, but it may not address the problems participants are most motivated to solve.
A more flexible approach could allow participants to select one instructional challenge and apply the workshop concepts to that problem. Everyone would still demonstrate the required skills, but the resulting work would have immediate relevance to their teaching. This connection between learning and personal goals can support engagement because participants see a reason to invest effort beyond simply completing the requirement.
Choice alone, however, does not guarantee motivation. Learners also need appropriate support, clear expectations, opportunities to experience progress, and confidence that the task is achievable. Instructional designers should treat choice as one component of a supportive learning environment rather than a solution to every engagement problem.
Choice Helps Adults Connect Learning to Real Life
Adult learning becomes particularly meaningful when learners can connect new knowledge with situations they encounter outside the classroom. These connections support the application of knowledge because learners begin recognizing when and where course concepts might be useful. Providing choices among authentic contexts can strengthen those relationships.
Consider a course introducing principles of effective communication. Learners could analyze communication challenges in healthcare, business, education, nonprofit organizations, or community settings. Each context would involve different circumstances, but the underlying communication principles would remain consistent. Allowing learners to select a relevant situation gives them an opportunity to apply common concepts to problems they understand or expect to encounter.
This approach also helps instructional designers avoid relying on examples that represent only one professional background. Adult learners often come from diverse industries and life experiences, and a single set of examples may not connect equally well with everyone. Offering several relevant contexts can make learning more accessible without requiring major changes to the course structure.
The goal is not to make every assignment personally customized. It is creating enough flexibility that learners can recognize how the knowledge applies beyond the immediate instructional environment. When learners can make those connections, the course becomes more than a series of required activities.
Choice and Universal Design for Learning
Universal Design for Learning (UDL) provides another useful framework for thinking about learner choice. The CAST UDL Guidelines encourage educators to anticipate learner variability and provide options that support engagement, representation, and action and expression. Rather than assuming every learner will respond equally well to one approach, UDL encourages flexible learning environments that reduce unnecessary barriers.
Within this framework, choice can support engagement by allowing learners to connect activities with their interests and goals. Options for demonstrating learning may also help learners communicate their understanding through appropriate methods, provided those methods still measure the intended learning outcomes. Flexibility becomes particularly useful when a specific format or activity introduces barriers unrelated to the knowledge or skills being assessed.
For example, if the learning objective requires students to evaluate the effectiveness of an instructional strategy, learners might be able to demonstrate that evaluation through a written analysis or an accessible recorded presentation. Both options could require the same evidence, reasoning, and conclusions. However, if the objective specifically requires formal academic writing, a written assessment would remain necessary because writing is part of the skill being measured.
This distinction illustrates why accessibility and instructional alignment must work together. Choice should remove unnecessary barriers without changing what learners are expected to accomplish. Effective UDL implementation involves thoughtful planning rather than simply providing multiple formats for every activity.
Too Much Choice Can Become Overwhelming
Although learner autonomy is important, excessive choice can create its own challenges. When students encounter too many options without sufficient guidance, they may spend more time deciding what to do than actually completing the learning activity. This can be particularly frustrating when learners are unfamiliar with the subject or uncertain about which option best supports their goals.
Imagine an instructor offering students twelve possible assignment formats, fifteen potential project topics, and several different submission methods. While the intention may be to provide flexibility, the number of decisions could become an additional cognitive burden. Learners may worry about selecting the wrong option or choosing something more difficult than necessary. Instead of feeling supported, they may experience uncertainty and frustration.
Instructional designers can address this problem by offering a manageable number of meaningful choices. Two or three well-developed options are often more useful than an extensive menu of possibilities. Each option should include clear instructions, comparable expectations, and enough information for learners to make an informed decision.
Providing a recommended pathway can also help learners who prefer more structure. For example, an instructor might offer three project topics while identifying one as a useful starting point for students who are new to the subject. Learners who want greater independence can select another option, while those who need guidance still have a clear direction. Choice becomes supportive rather than overwhelming.
Build Choice Into Assessments Without Sacrificing Rigor
Assessment is one of the most practical places to incorporate meaningful learner choice. When thoughtfully designed, flexible assessments allow learners to demonstrate the same knowledge or skills through different contexts or appropriate formats. The important consideration is ensuring that every option provides comparable evidence of the intended learning outcomes.
Consider a graduate course in instructional design where learners must evaluate an existing learning experience and recommend improvements. One student might evaluate a university course, another could examine a corporate training program, and a third might analyze a professional certification workshop. The subject matter would differ, but all three students would use the same evaluation framework and demonstrate the same analytical skills.
A common rubric can help maintain consistency across these options. Criteria might evaluate the quality of the analysis, application of instructional principles, supporting evidence, and appropriateness of the recommendations. The rubric would assess the intended learning rather than rewarding one professional context over another.
Instructional designers should also consider workload when developing assessment choices. An option requiring substantially more time, technology, or specialized resources may not be equivalent to the alternatives. Providing flexibility requires evaluating whether the choices are reasonably comparable and accessible. The goal is offering different pathways to the same learning destination, not creating separate standards for different learners.
Self-Directed Learning Still Requires Support
Adult learners are often described as self-directed, but that does not mean every adult arrives with the skills needed to manage an unfamiliar learning experience independently. Self-direction involves setting goals, monitoring progress, evaluating resources, and making decisions about learning strategies. These abilities develop through experience and may vary depending on the subject and learning environment.
An experienced professional may demonstrate considerable independence within their field while needing substantial guidance when learning a completely unfamiliar technology. Likewise, a student returning to college after many years may have strong workplace problem-solving skills but limited familiarity with online learning systems. Assuming that adulthood automatically produces strong self-directed learning skills can leave some learners without necessary support.
Instructional designers can encourage self-direction by gradually increasing opportunities for decision-making. Early activities might provide a limited number of options with clear guidance, while later assignments allow learners to select topics, identify resources, or propose their own approaches. This progression helps learners develop confidence as they gain knowledge and experience.
Reflection can also support self-directed learning. Asking learners to explain why they selected a particular approach, evaluate its effectiveness, and identify what they would change next time encourages metacognition. Choice becomes more educationally meaningful when learners consider not only what they selected but how that decision affected their learning.
Designing Choice in Online Courses
Online learning environments provide numerous opportunities to incorporate learner choice, but those options should be organized carefully. Without clear navigation and instructions, flexibility can become confusing. Instructional designers should ensure that learners understand which activities are required, where choices are available, and how their selections affect course expectations.
One practical approach is to provide a common learning pathway with selected opportunities for choice. Every learner might complete the same foundational readings and practice activities before choosing among several application assignments. Another course might allow students to select a case study related to their professional interests while maintaining a consistent submission process and grading rubric.
Learning management systems can support these approaches through organized content modules, assignment instructions, discussion topics, and optional enrichment resources. However, the technology should not determine whether a choice is instructionally appropriate. The learning objectives and learner needs should guide the design decisions, with technology serving as a means of implementation.
Clear communication is particularly important when learners have multiple options. Assignment descriptions should explain what students must accomplish, which elements are flexible, and how their work will be evaluated. When those expectations are established from the beginning, choice can support independence without introducing unnecessary uncertainty.
Respecting Choice Means Respecting Different Learners
One of the most important considerations in adult learning is that not everyone wants the same amount of independence. Some learners appreciate opportunities to make numerous decisions about their learning, while others prefer clearly structured activities with limited options. These preferences may reflect prior experience, confidence, available time, familiarity with the subject, or the demands of other responsibilities.
Instructional designers should avoid assuming that learners who prefer structure are less motivated or less capable. A professional balancing full-time employment, family responsibilities, and graduate coursework may appreciate a clearly defined assignment because it reduces the number of decisions required during an already demanding week. Another learner may welcome the opportunity to pursue a personally meaningful topic in greater depth. Both approaches can support meaningful learning.
Respecting learner differences means creating environments where appropriate structure and meaningful autonomy coexist. A course can provide a recommended pathway while allowing learners to select alternatives when those alternatives support the same objectives. It can establish consistent deadlines while offering flexibility in project topics. It can maintain common assessment standards while allowing learners to connect their work with different professional experiences.
The goal is not to require every adult learner to become completely independent. It is providing appropriate opportunities for ownership while ensuring that everyone has the guidance needed to succeed.
Final Thoughts
Choice matters in adult learning because adults bring different experiences, goals, responsibilities, and expectations into the classroom. Meaningful opportunities for decision-making can support autonomy, strengthen motivation, and help learners connect new knowledge with situations that matter to them. When learners have some ownership over their learning experiences, they may become more willing to engage with challenging tasks and take responsibility for their progress.
For instructional designers, incorporating choice requires more than offering several assignment formats or allowing students to select a topic. Effective choice must align with learning objectives, maintain appropriate academic expectations, remain accessible, and provide enough structure to support informed decisions. Too little flexibility can make learning feel unnecessarily restrictive, while too much can create confusion and additional cognitive demands. The challenge is finding a balance that respects learner independence without leaving learners to navigate the experience alone.
Adult learning is not about removing every expectation or allowing learners to determine every aspect of instruction. It is about acknowledging that learners arrive with knowledge, experiences, and goals that deserve consideration. Thoughtful instructional design creates opportunities for those experiences to contribute to the learning process while helping learners develop new capabilities.
The goal is not to give adult learners unlimited choices. It is giving them meaningful choices that help them take ownership of their learning while continuing to grow.
References
CAST. (2024). CAST Universal Design for Learning guidelines version 3.0. https://udlguidelines.cast.org/
Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (1985). Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behavior. Plenum Press.
Knowles, M. S., Holton, E. F., III, & Swanson, R. A. (2020). The adult learner: The definitive classic in adult education and human resource development (9th ed.). Routledge.
Merriam, S. B., & Bierema, L. L. (2014). Adult learning: Linking theory and practice. Jossey-Bass.
Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2020). Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation from a self-determination theory perspective: Definitions, theory, practices, and future directions. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 61, Article 101860. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2020.101860
Wlodkowski, R. J., & Ginsberg, M. B. (2017). Enhancing adult motivation to learn: A comprehensive guide for teaching all adults (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.